Home>Articles>‘Corporate-Free Elections Act’ Gets Shelved by Assembly Elections Committee

Assemblyman Alex Lee. (Photo: votealexlee.com)

‘Corporate-Free Elections Act’ Gets Shelved by Assembly Elections Committee

Freshman Assemblyman gets dressing down for half-baked bill

By Katy Grimes, April 30, 2021 2:15 am

A half-baked, complicated bill aiming to take all corporate money out of California political campaign contributions failed to pass out of the Assembly Elections Committee Thursday. But what was so interesting was that Assemblyman Marc Berman, Chairman of the Committee on Elections, gave a real dressing down to the bill’s author, freshman Assemblyman Alex Lee (D-San Jose).

It doesn’t happen often enough.

According to Assemblyman Lee, this is the purpose of Assembly Bill 20:

“What this bill aims to accomplish is not a radical idea – 22 States and the Federal Government have successfully enacted similar measures that prohibit business entities from directly financing a candidate’s election for public office. Passing AB 20 will bring us in conformity with the Federal government. Many other States have pushed similar reforms through their Legislatures to restore the public’s faith in democracy and addresses the systemic and perceived influence of corporate special interests over everyday people.”

“It is past time to rectify the undue influence that corporations have had in our democracy since the Supreme Court’s disastrous 2010 ruling on Citizens United v. FEC. With deepening income inequality and wealthy people afforded more political influence, we must commit to our values that every person has an equal voice in the political process and reaffirm a representative democracy for the people, not corporate executives and the rich.”

At the heart of the issue, according to Assemblyman Berman is that the actual bill language “falls woefully short from supporters’ claims of what this bill will accomplish.”

Assemblyman Marc Berman. (Photo: Kevin Sanders for California Globe)

Berman said he instructed Freshman Assemblyman Lee back in November, before Lee was even sworn in, to read the committee analysis from the last legislative session, when Assemblyman Evan Low (D-Campbell) authored a similar bill to take corporate contributions out of politics.

“You did not do this,”Berman said. Instead, Berman said Lee added a “findings and declarations” section that describes the problem. “And you bemoan the fact that hundreds of millions of dollars were spent in 2020 ballot initiatives – your bill does nothing — absolutely nothing — to restrict corporate spending in ballot initiatives.”

The bill analysis explains: “in this bill specifies that ‘corporations contribute hundreds of millions of dollars to campaigns for state and local offices across California,’ and notes as an example that ‘in 2020 it was found that more than $785 million was spent to influence voters on ballot measures alone, with millions more spent on individual races.’ These findings, however, may provide an inaccurate picture of the likely effects of this bill, and of the extent of contributions from business entities to candidates for elective office in California.”

Berman noted that the language Lee uses in his bill is very different from the 22 other states which have enacted similar measures. “Using the term ‘business entity’ as your bill does creates a loophole so big an armored truck could drive through.” In effect, AB 20 would actually prohibit businesses from donating directly to political candidates.

Several of the Elections Committee expressed their own concerns including that unless the campaign contribution playing field is leveled at the same time for all potential contributors, AB 20 only creates an imbalance.

“While this bill prohibits business entities from making contributions to candidates for elective office, it does not specify whether such entities are permitted to make contributions to political action committees (PACs) that contribute to candidates,” bill analysis explains. “If business entities are permitted to make such contributions, would the PAC be required to deposit contributions from business entities into a separate account with the funds in that account unavailable for making contributions to candidates?”

The bill prohibits “business entities” from making political contributions, but it does not prohibit labor unions from doing the same. Assemblyman Lee’s claim that there is “over-bloated spending in elections, is dubious without addressing all spending, including labor unions’ “over-bloated spending” in AB 20.

The bill was not even voted on. Assemblyman Berman told Assemblyman Lee to spend some time speaking to experts if he plans to consider bringing the bill back next legislative session.

Assemblyman Alex Lee is a bit of a celebrity in the California Legislature as he is the youngest elected Assembly member in 80 years. He worked in the district office of Assemblyman Evan Low (D-Campbell) prior to running for Assembly.

“Alex Lee (李天明) is the State Assemblymember representing the 25th District,” Lee’s bio on his campaign website says. “Prior to his election in 2020, he served as a Legislative Policy Advisor in the California State Senate and Assembly.”

“Alex is a progressive Democrat who serves on the Assembly Committees on Budget, Education, Privacy & Consumer Protections, and Transportation.”

“Alex made history in 2020 as the first Gen Z, youngest Asian American, and first bisexual state legislator in California history.” Many news articles after his election focused on his age; Alex Lee is 25. “The Generation Z Democrat from San Jose is 25 years old, lives with his mom and, up until recently, was working part time for an app-based delivery service to make ends meet during his campaign,” the Los Angeles Times reported.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Spread the news:


4 thoughts on “‘Corporate-Free Elections Act’ Gets Shelved by Assembly Elections Committee

  1. What a soldier that Berman guy! Right in lockstep with the rest of the Gimmedats.
    What has gnawed at me for years was in the 90s I walked the halls of the State house. attempting to persuade the legislatures about a particular issue. There posted on the door before the legislatures name was the word HONORABLE.
    Excuse me, but to this day when I think of the misuse of that word I want to vomit.

  2. Kinda funny, given some of the players here. Can’t really blame Young Whippersnapper and Baby Progressive Alex Lee for making a mess of things when he is only trying to ape the wacky ideas and role modeling of the Elder Progressives. And correct me if I’m wrong, but this is not the first atrociously written CA legislative bill? Ha.

  3. This is AOC-Sanders wing versus Pelosi-Schumer side playing out at the state level. Wishing pox on both.

  4. Ha, I wish I could get excited for the dressing down but as all here have expressed, most bills written these days should not see the light of day. A very young progressive authoring half baked bills what could possibly go wrong? He is destined to be a life long politician, doing the peoples work!
    The former door dash driver has authored AB 1509 – Dropping severe penalty enhancements of convicted gun violence criminals from 25 years to life to 1,2 or 3 years.
    I suppose he did his “homework” on that one, not! It will add to the growing crime in our state!

    Wake up good people of Milpitas, South Fremont, Santa Clara and Newark! Make him a young one termer, the guy needs some life experience.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.