Home>Articles>San Francisco to Become First U.S. City to Reach Herd Immunity Later This Month

San Francisco Skyline (Photo: Evan Symon for California Globe)

San Francisco to Become First U.S. City to Reach Herd Immunity Later This Month

68% of all San Franciscans 12 and older have been fully vaccinated, 79% have received at least one dose

By Evan Symon, June 8, 2021 11:32 am

According to numerous health experts this week, San Francisco will likely become the first major U.S. city to reach herd immunity, which it is set to do by the end of this month.

San Francisco County health officials have noted that 79% of San Franciscans 12 and older have received at least one dose, with 68% of all San Franciscans 12 and older fully vaccinated. The California Department of Health has put the total number of doses given in San Francisco County at just over 1.1 million, backing up San Francisco’s figures.

Herd immunity is generally agreed to be at around 75% of the population, with U.S. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) Director and the chief medical advisor to the president Dr. Anthony Fauci recently stating the vaccination percentage at 70%-75%.

With vaccination figures so close, experts have noted that herd immunity is coming soon to the city by the bay.

“I’d say it’s pretty close,” said UCSF epidemiologist Dr. George Rutherford on Monday. “San Francisco is around three weeks away.”

San Francisco has been unusually quick in getting residents vaccinated, already hitting the 20% bar of having at least one dose given to those 16-an-up before March 1st, and then following it up by breaking experts estimations week after week throughout the spring.

“There is no other city that has these numbers of first dose vaccinations, even in places that vaccinated faster than we,” noted UCSF Dr. Monica Gandhi.

Other experts even noted that San Francisco bucking the national trend and vaccinating residents by leaps and bounds over other cities worldwide made it something of an anomaly.

“We have small towns in places like New England and West Virginia becoming fully vaccinated, but larger cities in those areas like Boston or Hartford are at only around 60% fully vaccinated now,” Horace Clark, a COVID-19 researcher who keeps track of vaccination rates in urban areas in the U.S., noted to the Globe on Tuesday. “And then cities across the U.S. drop off to 50% vaccinated. 40%. 30%. Then, when we reach California, it curves up again. Los Angeles and San Diego go above 50%, and then you get to the Bay Area and San Francisco, where they are outdoing East Coast cities who only a few months ago wee shaking their heads at California for being the pandemic epicenter.”

San Francisco’s success will also likely pave the way for other areas to get to herd immunity, but due to falling fully vaccinated and first dose numbers, California will not reach herd immunity by either California’s reopening date of June 15th or California’s original goal of July 15th.

San Francisco to reach herd immunity by late June, all of California by mid-September

With only 53.3% of the entire state’s population now fully vaccinated, and 11.9% only partially vaccinated, California is now likely to reach herd immunity by the end of summer in September.

“I think on a practical point we’re closing in on it now, as far as a formal definition of 75% of people vaccinated, including children, I think it’s going to take longer towards the end of the summer,” explained Dr. Rutherford. “If that pace keeps up, it’s likely California will reach full herd immunity levels by mid-September.”

“I agree with that, that we are getting there,” added Dr. Gandhi.

While many health experts are already noting that nationwide herd immunity will likely not happen due to aversion against the vaccine being higher in many places outside of California, some hold out hope that San Francisco and, later, California reaching the 75% vaccination mark could help bring the country around.

“California is the first in the nation on so much, and really influences other states to follow it,” remarked Clark. “It may influence other states to match them. God knows that they have done this countless times before. Many hope that will be the case, but we aren’t holding our breath on it.”

For San Francisco and the rest of the state, the first real test of heightened vaccinations will come later this month when the state reopens on June 15th. If COVID-19 rates stay low, it may dampen vaccine demand.

“There will be more mingling, there will be people around each other, we’re going to watch those cases very carefully and if they don’t go up which I suspect they won’t, that’s when you say, yeah, we’ve gotten to herd immunity,” explained Dr. Gandhi. “You have to test it with human interaction within the population.”

And experts warn that while San Francisco will still likely get the honor of being the first large city in the country to reach herd immunity, California may fall short.

“If all looks good and normal, many on the fence of getting the vaccine won’t,” added Clark. “And all the vaccination lotteries in the state won’t change that.”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Evan Symon
Spread the news:


10 thoughts on “San Francisco to Become First U.S. City to Reach Herd Immunity Later This Month

  1. People keep stressing “herd immunity” wrt the percentage of the population being VACCINATED. This seems misleading since it ignores NATURAL immunity resulting from asymptomatic infections (which no one seems to have a handle on) and built-up antibodies. It seems to me that we could be into herd immunity NOW with only an average 50% of the population being vaccinated; assuming 20%-25% or more in the asymptomatic group. Is San Francisco, supposed to be a “model” city? I doubt it.

    1. The differences between vaccine-induced and natural immunity are complex. The vaccine induces antibodies specifically against the spike protein, and so far no variants have sufficiently different spike protein to completely evade those antibodies. Natural immunity can come from different responses in the immune system, and not all of those actually resist variants effectively or maintain long-term immunity.

      So the upshot is: re-infection, especially by variants, is much more common in people who’ve had the disease and are not vaccinated than breakthrough infections in people who are vaccinated. “Herd immunity” isn’t the same in unvaccinated populations. If you survived the disease, you’d be smart to follow Trump’s example and get vaccinated anyway.

  2. Note how they hack the term “herd immunity.” It used to be natural vaccination (i.e. having antibodies) was included, so you could throw in people with a positive antibody test – which should include everyone who is vaccinated. But they don’t even count people who are naturally immune – presumably they had this or a similar virus (assuming it exists – and this is debatable), but because the Vaccine Mafia wants to increase sales, all they do is tag people who had an artificial immunity. It’s so corrupt. Just like San Francisco.

    1. So,… vaccinating people against a pandemic is,… “so corrupt”? That makes no sense.

      1. It is not a vaccine. It is an experimental gene therapy with many unknowns. Now they have moved on to children. So they are now doing an experimental therapy on children as an experiment. Many expert scientists are being silenced when they speak out against it, why??? Why the rush? When herd immunity was only recognized in natural immunity the vaccine makers said that there was no such thing. Now suddenly we get herd immunity from vaccines only?? Time will tell us that these are crimes against humanity, over 5000 dead in the US in just 5 months. That’s more than all of the vaccines in the last 20 yrs. Why is it still going and why are they moving on to children?

        1. @April: Are you really serious with that post? You seem to have latched onto separate concepts and mixed them up.

          1. 95 percent of people who get any of the three vaccines become immune to Covid. That makes it a “vaccine” no matter what you want to call it or not.

          2. “Gene therapy” involves modifying an individual’s genome. mRNA can’t do that. It inserts instructions into cells that cause them to manufacture a specific protein, but it doesn’t cause any kind of DNA change. There is no way for the mRNA instructions to persist in the cell long-term, nor to be transfered into a different cell or into daughter cells.

          3. Michael Yeadon is one ex-Pfizer scientist whose claims about reproductive harm have no evidence to support them. That doesn’t prove he is “wrong,” because ideas aren’t “Science” unless there’s some test that could prove them wrong. It’s just very unlikely that he is right, because there’s no evidence. And he’s alone. There are no “many expert scientists” being silenced who agree with him. It’s simply not true.

          4. Why the rush? Because thousands of people die every day of COVID. Do I really have to say this: “Duh!”

  3. Herd immunity includes natural immunity. “Doctor” Fauci has admitted to manipulating estimates for herd immunity in order to sell vaccines.

    California Globe has had great reporting through the lockdowns, but over this year they’ve adopted the communist narrative.

    P.S. Masks do nothing.

    1. Could we please rely on evidence over gut feelings? Look up the article in The Lancet “Risk of SARS-CoV-2 reinfection after natural infection.” It’s respectable and reliable, and it explains why vaccines induce more effective immunity than infection. That’s why Trump got vaccinated even though he’d recovered from the disease.

      P.S.: Masks plus social distancing are about as effective as 60 percent vaccination at stopping the spread.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *