California State Capitol. (Photo: Katy Grimes for California Globe)
Textualism v. Purposivism in California Courts
Unlike federal courts influenced by modern textualism, California has codified its rejection of pure textualism
By Chris Micheli, November 16, 2026 2:30 am
In California courts, strict textualism generally fails when a literal reading of a statute conflicts with a clear legislative purpose, because California’s framework is fundamentally purposivist, legally mandating that judicial interpretation must pursue the intent of the Legislature and promote underlying public policy over formalistic text.
While California courts use the “plain meaning rule” as a baseline starting point, a rigid textualist approach is routinely rejected or overridden by public policy mandates under several well-defined legal doctrines, including legislative intent, absurdity doctrine, and the whole act.
Unlike federal courts influenced by modern textualism, California has codified its rejection of pure textualism. California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1859, which was enacted in 1872, explicitly commands that “in the construction of a statute the intention of the legislature… is to be pursued, if possible.” In addition, Government Code Section 9080 states that official legislative records and history constitute vital evidence of intent, permitting courts to bypass a purely semantic text-bound analysis.
In addition, textualism fails completely when a literal application of the text yields an absurd result that frustrates the explicitly stated policy goals of the law. In seminal cases like People v. Coronado (1995), the California Supreme Court established that the plain meaning rule does not compel a court to follow literal language if doing so defeats the legislative intent. In a similar manner, People v. Pieters (1991) demonstrated that the judiciary will actively depart from a literal reading if it introduces anomalies that contradict the system of law the Legislature designed.
Finally, California courts view statutory words not as isolated, static definitions, but as the “skin of a living thought” that changes color based on the broader context (Pearson v. State Social Welfare Bd.). Under the Whole Act Rule, if a strict textual interpretation of an individual word or sub-clause undermines the overarching statutory scheme or explicit legislative findings, textualism fails.
As the California Supreme Court in North American Title Co. v. Superior Court (2024) stated, the core judicial obligation is to evaluate how a statute fits into the broader legal system and choose an interpretation that advances the underlying public policy rather than allowing a technical loophole.
- Textualism v. Purposivism in California Courts - November 16, 2026
- How Do California Courts Define an Ambiguous Statute? - November 15, 2026
- Drafting Statutory Enforcement in California - November 15, 2026



