Justice Court. (Photo: Nirat.pix/Shutterstock)
Arizona Chief Justice Seeks Retention Election Changes After Voters Reject Three Judges
Republican and progressive groups targeted judges for different reasons as the chief justice considers longer terms and a higher threshold for removal
By Matthew Holloway, November 16, 2026 11:39 am
Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice Ann Scott Timmer is seeking changes to the state’s judicial retention system following election results rejecting three judges who received favorable evaluations from the state’s judicial performance commission.
Timmer described the system as “broken” and plans to convene a committee to examine the election and consider changes before 2028, according to Capitol Media Services reporting published by the Arizona Daily Star. Ideas include longer judicial terms and increasing the percentage of votes required to remove a judge.
“Losing these three judges is devastating,” Timmer told the outlet, expressing concern about recruiting and retaining qualified judges.
The judges are Arizona Court of Appeals Judge Anni Hill Foster and Maricopa County Superior Court Judges Julie Mata and Michael Rassas. All three were appointed by former Republican Gov. Doug Ducey and met the Arizona Commission on Judicial Performance Review’s standards, according to the Arizona Capitol Times.
Unofficial results cited in that report showed approximately 50.2% opposed Foster’s retention, 51.35% opposed Mata’s, and 50.6% opposed Rassas’.
The Maricopa County Republican Committee’s published judicial guide recommended voting against all three. Its list did not provide individual explanations for those recommendations.
📷 YOUR ONE-STOP RESOURCE FOR THE 2026 ARIZONA BALLOT
Trying to sort through everything on your ballot this year?https://t.co/h4F3zIFeym makes it easy to navigate the races, candidates, judges, and propositions Arizona voters will see on their ballots:Congress
Statewide…
— Arizona Free Enterprise Club (@azfec) September 22, 2026
Progressive organization Civic Engagement Beyond Voting also recommended rejecting Foster and Mata. Its Gavel Watch recommendation sheet, distributed by Legislative District 2 Democrats, expressed “Reservations” about Rassas without placing him in its “Do Not Retain” category.
Did you miss our first presentation on your 2026 ballot? It's not too late to get informed! You've got 3 more chances — sign up to attend one of our upcoming events at https://t.co/tkc2oV44BD pic.twitter.com/1pByGu5rs4
— Civic Engagement Beyond Voting (@AZCEBVus) September 17, 2026
The campaigns raised different objections to the judges.
According to KTAR, Legislative District 4 Republicans criticized Foster’s participation in a ruling permitting Maricopa County to withhold electronic records showing how ballots were marked. Progressive critics objected to her earlier work as Ducey’s attorney, including a Supreme Court brief supporting the reversal of Roe v. Wade.
The Capitol Times reported that progressive opposition to Mata included her handling of litigation over diversity, equity, and inclusion and school-choice ballot proposals. Gavel Watch also cited concerns arising from her performance surveys.
Mata appeared on signs sponsored by Arizonans for Judicial Accountability urging voters to reject judges, the Daily Star reported.
Mata separately faced criticism from attorney David Gingras following her ruling against his client, Laura Owens, in paternity litigation involving former “The Bachelor” star Clayton Echard. Gingras encouraged litigants to request another judge and filed a misconduct complaint. The Commission on Judicial Conduct dismissed the complaint after finding insufficient clear and convincing evidence of ethical misconduct, KTAR reported.
Republican objections to Rassas included parental-rights decisions, with LD4 Republicans citing an appellate reversal involving a father’s past housing problems. Gavel Watch’s reservations included negative attorney responses concerning judicial temperament. The Maricopa County Democratic Party recommended rejecting Foster and Mata but did not include Rassas in its recommendations, according to KTAR and the Capitol Times.
Timmer’s proposed review comes two years after voters rejected Proposition 137 by approximately 77.7%. Gavel Watch founder Cathy Sigmon defended voter guides as a response to public demand for information about judges, according to the Daily Star.
Proposition 137’s text, referred to voters through Senate Concurrent Resolution 1044, would have replaced regular terms for covered judges with service during good behavior and restricted retention elections to specified circumstances. Those included certain criminal convictions, personal bankruptcy, mortgage foreclosure, or a finding that a judge failed to meet judicial performance standards.
Arizona’s debate over voters’ authority to remove judges dates back before the then-Arizona Territory achieved statehood. President William Howard Taft vetoed a statehood resolution on August 15, 1911, largely because Arizona’s proposed constitution allowed judicial recall, according to the National Archives.
That dispute concerned recall elections. Arizona’s modern merit-selection and retention system was adopted in 1974. Timmer’s effort remains preliminary, with no finalized constitutional amendment identified in the November 14 report.
- Arizona Chief Justice Seeks Retention Election Changes After Voters Reject Three Judges - November 16, 2026
- SpaceX Plans $50 Billion AI Campus In Arizona’s Cochise County - November 16, 2026
- ‘We Can’t Stop Legislation’: Incoming Arizona Senate GOP Leader Kavanagh Outlines Minority Strategy - November 11, 2026




