Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, Victims, Prosecutors and Law Enforcement Sue Governor Newsom to Stop Blanket Death Row Commutations
The lawsuit challenges the Governor’s failure to provide legally required notice to district attorneys and his disregard for the rights of victims and their families
By Katy Grimes, November 16, 2026 11:47 am
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation has filed a lawsuit challenging Governor Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute all 548 California death sentences to life without the possibility of parole. Led by former Sacramento County District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert, “the lawsuit challenges the Governor’s failure to provide legally required notice to district attorneys and his disregard for the rights of victims and their families to be notified and heard. It further challenges the Governor’s abuse of executive clemency power in attempting to overturn hundreds of death sentences without complying with constitutional and statutory clemency requirements, without conducting meaningful individualized reviews, and in a manner that undermines the California Supreme Court’s constitutional role in the clemency process,” the CJLF announced Monday.
As the Globe reported Friday:
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation (CJLF) is leading a legal challenge to California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute all 548 death sentences to life without the possibility of parole (LWOP), with support from district attorneys and victims’ advocates.
In an open letter to Californians, Governor Gavin Newsom announced last week that he is commuting the death sentences of all 548 convicts on California’s death row, to life in prison without the possibility of parole, the Globe reported November 5, 2026.
“I take this action because I firmly believe that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values, undermines the foundations of our legal system, and diminishes all of us,” Gov. Newsom said.
“This lawsuit is about protecting the constitutional rights of victims, defending the rule of law, and ensuring that no Governor is above the law,” said Anne Marie Schubert, President and CEO of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation. “The Governor’s clemency power does not authorize mass commutations that disregard constitutional safeguards, legally required procedures, or victims’ rights. By predetermining the outcome for every inmate on death row, the Governor has abandoned his responsibility to exercise meaningful discretion. Blanket commutation is not an exercise of discretion — it is an abandonment of it.”
The effort has support from Los Angeles County DA Nathan Hochman, Orange County DA Todd Spitzer, San Luis Obispo DA Dan Dow, as well as victims’ and law enforcement organizations.
They are urging the California Supreme Court to reject mass clemency in favor of case-by-case review.
“District attorneys have a legal responsibility to represent the people of California and protect the rights of crime victims,” said Greg Totten, CEO of the California District Attorneys Association. “The Governor’s failure to provide legally required notice to prosecutors has deprived them of the opportunity to provide critical information and ensure that victims and their families are heard. No Governor should be permitted to circumvent the very safeguards designed to ensure that justice is served.”
As we noted, Gov. Newsom ran for governor on a vow to uphold California voters’ support of the death penalty, yet he announced in March 2019, shortly after taking office, that he would grant reprieves for all death penalty murderers on California’s death row. He called the death penalty “ineffective, irreversible and immoral.”
The CJLF says Newsom’s announcement disregards voter will, as Californians rejected death-penalty repeal measures, Prop 34 in 2012 and Prop 62 in 2016, while approving reforms, Prop 66, to expedite the process.
So Newsom claiming he can commute the death penalty sentences to life without possibility of parole is disingenuous – LWOP is not necessarily permanent, because legislatures can later change rules, as the California Legislature did.
This is the largest proposed mass commutation of death sentences in U.S. history.
“Behind every one of these death sentences are victims, grieving families, and lives forever shattered,” said Topo Padilla, President of Crime Victims United. “Many of these families were horrified to learn of the Governor’s plans through the news rather than from the very government entrusted to protect their rights. After years, and often decades, of fighting for justice, they are once again being forced to relive their worst nightmare. Victims are not an afterthought in our justice system. They have constitutional rights, and those rights must be respected.”
San Luis Obispo District Attorney Dan Dow told Gov. Newsom on X:
Before issuing blanket commutations for all 548 of California’s death sentences, including some of the worst of the worst murderers in our state’s history, you should read what Theodore Roosevelt wrote about the clemency power.
In his 1913 Autobiography, TR said there were certain crimes for which “requests for leniency merely made me angry.” He listed rape, the “white slave” traffic, wife murder, gross cruelty to women and children, and inducing abortion. When prominent men petitioned for leniency in such cases, he replied that he “extremely regretted that it was not in my power to increase the sentence,” then made the petitioners’ names public because he believed they “deserved public censure.”
That is the opposite of your choosing to treat every capital case the same with a single blanket act. California voters have repeatedly affirmed the death penalty for the worst of the worst.
Read Roosevelt’s full account, then explain why mass clemency for the state’s most heinous killers is the better course.
Waiting for your reply.
Read the Petition for Writ of Mandate filed November 15, 2026:
6afb30ad63bad6a49ad08a15_ClemencyWrit- Gavin Newsom Visits War Torn Ukraine, but Neglects California’s Devastation - November 17, 2026
- California’s Women’s Caucus Celebrates ‘Gender Parity’ in the Legislature, But Can’t Tell You What a Woman Is - November 16, 2026
- Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, Victims, Prosecutors and Law Enforcement Sue Governor Newsom to Stop Blanket Death Row Commutations - November 16, 2026




