Home>Articles>Protecting American Innovation: When Patent Rights Are Not Enough

Collision Communications wireless-technology developer. (Photo: collision.com)

Protecting American Innovation: When Patent Rights Are Not Enough

A patent should represent a meaningful property right, not simply a price tag that a financially powerful corporation can eventually be required to pay

By Katy Grimes, November 21, 2026 9:00 am

A federal jury awarded New Hampshire-based Collision Communications $445.5 million in October of 2025 after finding Samsung willfully infringed its patents, yet the company is still fighting to stop Samsung from using its technology.

In August the Globe reported on patent infringement case Collision Communications, Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al.,  in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas. 

The importance of this patent infringement case cannot be stressed enough.

Collision Communications, a New Hampshire company, won a $445.5 million jury verdict against Samsung Electronics in October 2025. The court later declined to order Samsung to stop infringing, and that case regarding an injunction to stop importing infringing products is now on appeal. The dispute raises a broader question for American inventors, research companies, universities, and technology businesses: whether a patent is an enforceable property right or only a claim to payment.

But what happens when powerful corporations benefit from that innovation without respecting the intellectual property rights of those who developed it? The case of New Hampshire-based Collision Communications, Inc. versus Samsung Electronics offers a troubling example.

A Guilty Verdict Against Samsung

Collision Communications acquired signal-processing technology originally developed by defense contractor BAE Systems. The technology was designed to reduce signal interference and improve wireless communications, with applications in military communications.  Collision invested significant funds and developed several improvements to the signal processing and transformed it to work on commercial networks.

After making these investments in commercializing the technology and pursuing licensing opportunities with major companies, including Samsung, Collision filed a patent infringement lawsuit in December 2023 against Samsung. This stemmed from working with Samsung for several years and sharing information about the technology Collision had developed.

On October 10, 2025, a federal jury found that Samsung had infringed six asserted claims across four Collision patents, rejected Samsung’s arguments that the patents were invalid, and determined that the infringement was willful. The jury awarded Collision $445,494,160 in damages.

This was a significant victory for an American intellectual property owner. But the verdict did not end the dispute. Instead, the legal fight continued.

Winning a Verdict Does Not Mean the Infringement Stops

Collision subsequently sought a permanent injunction to prevent Samsung from continuing to infringe one of its patents. In May 2026, the federal court denied that request, despite agreeing that Collision had demonstrated irreparable harm and that monetary damages were inadequate to fully compensate for its injuries.

The court also agreed with the notion that Collision should not be disfavored simply because it operates as a non-practicing entity (NPE) but concluded that the legal requirements for an injunction had not been met.  Collision appealed the injunction decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.

In July 2026, the court awarded additional damages for post-verdict sales of infringing products, along with prejudgment interest. 

Those developments underscore the troubling reality: A jury found that Samsung willfully infringed an American company’s patents, yet Collision has had to continue the fight to obtain an order that would stop the challenged use of its own technology.

What message does this send to American inventors and businesses?

A $445.5 million verdict is substantial, but it does not necessarily restore control over an invention or prevent continued unauthorized use. A patent should represent a meaningful property right, not simply a price tag that a financially powerful corporation can eventually be required to pay.

In fact, Samsung has stated they will appeal the courts verdict. Consequently, it will further delay any payment to Collision, but more importantly the appeal process will allow Samsung to continue to use the patents possibly until they are all expired.

That is why injunctions matter.

Samsung’s size and global market position make this case particularly significant. Companies that benefit from American innovation should respect the intellectual property rights behind it; a finding of willful infringement should never be treated as simply another cost of doing business.

The Cost of Undermining American Innovation

The issue extends far beyond Collision Communications. Independent inventors, research and development companies, startups, universities, and non-practicing entities all contribute to America’s innovation economy. NPEs may license patented technology rather than manufacture products themselves, but that does not make their intellectual property less valuable. Research, engineering, testing, patent protection, and commercialization require capital and years of work. Licensing helps fund those investments and future innovation.

According to the National Science Foundation, American businesses performed approximately $765 billion in domestic research and development during 2024. When smaller innovators must spend years and substantial resources in court simply to enforce their intellectual property rights, the financial imbalance becomes difficult to ignore. The company that develops or acquires the technology bears the cost of protecting it, while a much larger corporation may continue benefiting from its use.

That is not an environment that encourages innovation or fair competition.

Congress Should Strengthen Patent Protections

The Constitution recognizes the importance of intellectual property, and federal patent law is intended to reward invention. Yet the Collision-Samsung dispute illustrates why Congress should examine whether current remedies adequately protect American patent owners, especially when a jury has found willful infringement.

Congress should consider targeted changes to patent law that make enforcement more effective and timely, reduce opportunities to prolong infringement through costly litigation, and ensure courts can provide meaningful relief when monetary damages alone are inadequate. Any reform should preserve judicial review and appropriate safeguards against abusive claims while ensuring that legitimate patent owners, including those who license rather than manufacture, can enforce their rights. 

In February 2026, the Department of Justice and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office filed a joint Statement of Interest in the Collision-Samsung litigation, emphasizing the importance of preserving incentives to innovate and ensuring meaningful patent protection, including for NPEs. Congress should take these concerns seriously. Protecting American innovation requires more than celebrating new inventions; it requires laws that give patent rights practical force.

Consumers Have a Role to Play

This case should concern every American who believes in private property rights, fair competition, and our nation’s technological future. We cannot expect American innovators to compete globally while making it increasingly difficult for them to protect the value of their work at home.

Americans have the power to protect American innovation through their purchasing decisions. When buying phones, televisions, tablets, or other electronics, consumers should consider more than price and brand recognition. They should ask whether the companies receiving their hard-earned dollars respect American inventors and intellectual property rights. Samsung’s record of patent infringement litigation raises serious questions about its treatment of American innovation. American consumers should think twice before supporting companies like Samsung that have been found liable for violating American patent rights. Choose to support companies that respect American inventors and the innovations that drive our nation’s future.

That scrutiny is especially warranted for Samsung in light of the Collision verdict. Consumers do not need to reject foreign-made electronics categorically to demand accountability. They can expect every company selling into the American market to respect the innovation and legal rights that help make those products possible.

American innovation deserves stronger protection. Samsung should be held accountable for infringement established by the jury, Congress should examine the gaps in patent enforcement, and consumers should recognize the power of their purchasing decisions. American intellectual property must never be treated as free for the taking.

 

References & Sources

1.  Katy Grimes. (August 18, 2026). Collision Communications v. Samsung: Landmark Patent Infringement. California Globe.

2.  Blake Brittain. (October 10, 2025). Samsung hit with $445.5 million US jury verdict over wireless communications patents. Reuters.

3.  Collision Communications, Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., No. 2:23-CV-00587-JRG (E.D. Tex. May 18, 2026). Memorandum Opinion and Order denying permanent injunction.

4.  Collision Communications, Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., No. 2:23-CV-00587-JRG (E.D. Tex. July 16, 2026). Memorandum Opinion and Order regarding supplemental damages and interest.

5.  U.S. Department of Justice. (February 27, 2026). Justice Department and U.S. Patent and Trademark Office File Statement of Interest Reaffirming the Importance of Incentives to Innovate.

6.  U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 – Intellectual Property Clause.

– United States Patent Act, 35 U.S.C. §§ 154, 271, 283, and 284 – Patent rights, infringement, injunctions, and damages.

7.  eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C., 547 U.S. 388 (2006).

8.  National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics. (2026). Business R&D Performance in the United States Increases to $765 Billion in 2024. National Science Foundation, NSF 27-301.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Spread the news:

 RELATED ARTICLES

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *