Home>Articles>Troubled Bridge Over Water

Collapsed portions of the Cypress Viaduct (left) and the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge (right). (Source: USGS)
Articles Butte Governor Highlight Legislature Local San Francisco

Troubled Bridge Over Water

Still-faulty San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge span used Chinese steel

By Lloyd Billingsley, October 2, 2019 12:55 pm

Chinese Communists have been celebrating the 70th anniversary of the People’s Republic, with Assemblywoman Wendy Carrillo, all decked out in red, joining in on the festivities. China’s totalitarian regime, a member of the World Trade Association since 2001, had more to celebrate when California opted to use Chinese steel on the new span of the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge.

That stylish structure came in 10 years late, $5 billion over budget, and riddled with safety issues that prompted Gov. Jerry Brown famously to quip, “I mean, look, shit happens.” Many of the problems, it turned out, stemmed from the use of Chinese steel.

In early 2014, State Sen. Mark DeSaulnier of the Transportation and Housing Committee held hearings on the troubled span. In 2013, dozens of the long metal rods on the project snapped and metallurgical engineer Lisa Thomas testified that this was due to hydrogen embrittlement. Caltrans invited this problem, Thomas testified, by opting to use Grade BD steel on the project, rather than the more robust Grade BC. Caltrans also outsourced work to China, where workers produced cracked welds.

Caltrans bridge engineer Douglas Coe noted that every one of the structure’s 750 panels had to be repaired. UC Berkeley structural engineering professor Abolhassan Astaneh-Asi, who knows a bit more about bridges than Jerry Brown, believes the structure is unsafe and declines to use it.

The destroyed section of I-880, SF-Oakland freeway (source: Federal Highway Admin)

DeSaulnier, a Concord Democrat, cited “a deliberate and willful attempt to obfuscate what is happening to the public.” Caltrans geologist Michael Moore testified that safety problems were kept secret, ignored and covered up. He called for a “criminal investigation,” but Attorney General Kamala Harris took no action.

That prompted a frustrated DeSaulnier to lament, “there’s never been anyone in the management of the bridge who has been held accountable.” DeSaulnier moved on to Congress, but the unaccountable Bay Area span is not the only state project with lingering safety issues.

The massive Oroville Dam, the nation’s highest and centerpiece of the State Water Project, was completed in 1968 and its emergency spillway designed by an unnamed graduate student. During torrential rains in February 2017, the spillway failed, prompting an evacuation order that sent 200,000 people running for shelter.

“Engineers have known for decades that Oroville’s backup spillway was unreliable,” ran a headline on a Sacramento Bee story. The report cited U.S. Rep. John Garamendi that “the emergency spillway remained basically a dirt, soil rock facility, and it worked fine until it had to be used, in which case it didn’t work so well.”

Oroville Dam spillway collapse (CDWR)

Governor Jerry Brown told reporters he was unaware of warnings about the emergency spillway and added, “I’m glad we found out about it.” As Brown explained, “We live in a world of risk. Stuff happens and we respond.”

Lloyd Billingsley

Lloyd Billingsley is the author of Sexual Terrorist, about the Golden State Killer, and A Shut and Open Case, about a California murder trial prolonged by Proposition 57 and recent legislation. Lloyd is a fellow with the Independent Institute and his work has appeared in the Daily Caller, City Journal, Orange County Register, Wall Street Journal and many other publications. Bill of Writes: Dispatches from the Political Correctness Battlefield is a collection of his journalism.

Latest posts by Lloyd Billingsley (see all)

Spread the news:
Filter by
Post Page
Feature Articles World News National Highlight Governor Legislature Congress
Sort by

CalPERS is Heavily Invested in Chinese Companies

As NBA frets over PRoC, Yu Ben Meng bets big with dollars from America’s largest pension fund
October 10, 2019 9:40 am


Why Is Ricardo Lara Quiet on Hundreds of Thousands of Homeowners Insurance Cancellations?

Calif. Insurance Commish cozies up to insurance industry while real estate crisis could be looming
September 6, 2019 8:28 am


Democrat Rep. Katie Porter Supports Impeachment of Trump, Has Her Own Ethics Concerns

California’s Katie Porter caught using her position in Congress for personal gain
June 18, 2019 10:00 am


One thought on “Troubled Bridge Over Water

  1. The Engineering Geologist referred to in the story is Michael Morgan, not Michael Moore. Hearings and newspaper articles relating to construction problems on the bridge began in late 2011.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *