California State Capitol. (Photo: Katy Grimes for California Globe)
Challenging ‘Underground Regulations’ at OAL
Regulated entities, and interested persons, can challenge unadopted agency rules
By Chris Micheli, November 17, 2026 9:09 am
The following is an essential step-by-step look at how regulated entities can file a petition under Title 1, Section 250 when an agency enforces informal memos, FAQs, or audit guidelines as if they were formal rules adopted pursuant to the APA.
Regulated entities, and interested persons, can challenge unadopted agency rules, such as informal memos, FAQs, audit guidelines, or internal manuals, by filing a petition for determination with the California Office of Administrative Law (OAL) under Title 1, Chapter 2 (Sections 250 through 280) of the California Code of Regulations (CCR) and Government Code Section 11340.5.
OAL’s Chapter Two Unit (CTU) reviews whether the challenged policy is an illegal “underground regulation,” which means that a rule of general application that interprets or implements law but bypassed formal Administrative Procedure Act (APA) adoption and filing. What approach should an interested party or regulated entity take to challenge possible underground regulations at the OAL?
Step 1: Verify the Rule Meets the Definition of an “Underground Regulation”
Before drafting, test the challenged agency practice against OAL’s core criteria under 1 CCR § 250 and § 11342.600:
- Is it a rule of general application? Does the agency apply the memo, guideline, or FAQ broadly to a class of regulated entities or situations, rather than just resolving a single, isolated case?
- Does it implement, interpret, or make specific a statute or regulation enforced by the agency, or govern internal agency procedure?
- Has it failed to go through public notice, comment, and filing with the Secretary of State under the APA, and does it lack an express statutory exemption?
Step 2: Gather Evidence of Enforcement
Collect concrete proof that the agency is actually using or enforcing the informal document such as with audit reports, inspection write-ups, or compliance letters citing the memo or FAQ. Is there email correspondence or written statements from agency staff stating that a guideline is “required” or “policy”? Do you have copies of the offending memo, training manual, slide deck, or FAQ page itself?
Step 3: Draft the Written Petition
Prepare the petition (you can use OAL’s optional guidance and template via the OAL’s Underground Regulations Page). The submission must include the following according to OAL:
- Name, address, and contact details of the individual, business, or industry association filing the petition.
- The exact name of the state department or board.
- Clear identification and an attached copy of the memo, FAQ, or audit guideline.
- A summary showing how and when the agency enforced the rule against you or similarly situated entities.
- Why the rule is a regulation under Government Code § 11342.600 and § 11340.5 rather than a valid, non-binding internal management memo or restatement of existing law.
- Evidence that a complete copy of the petition was formally served or delivered to the head of the challenged state agency.
Step 4: Submit the Petition to OAL
Deliver the written petition to OAL’s Chapter Two Unit either by mail or hand delivery to:
Office of Administrative Law
Attn: Chapter Two Unit (CTU)
300 Capitol Mall, Suite 1250
Sacramento, CA 95814
Or by email to: staff@oal.ca.gov
Step 5: OAL Review and Notice Period
OAL has up to 60 days to review the petition to determine whether it meets filing requirements. If accepted, OAL publishes notice of the petition in the California Regulatory Notice Register (CRNR). The challenged state agency has 45 calendar days from the CRNR publication date to submit a formal response to OAL. You (the petitioner) have 15 calendar days after receiving the agency’s response to submit a reply to OAL.
Step 6: OAL Issues a Determination
Within 120 calendar days (or up to 150 days if extended) of publication in the Notice Register, OAL issues a written Determination (or a summary disposition if the rule is found not to be an underground regulation). If the agency realizes it is vulnerable, it can issue a written certification to OAL prior to the determination stating it will stop using or enforcing the rule, which suspends OAL action.
An OAL determination that a rule is an underground regulation carries persuasive judicial weight and blocks the agency from legally enforcing it unless they officially adopt it through the full APA rulemaking process. If the agency refuses to relent, a judicial action (such as a writ of mandate) can be pursued in court.
- Challenging ‘Underground Regulations’ at OAL - November 17, 2026
- How to Draft a Legally Sound Special Statute Clause - November 17, 2026
- What Happens When a California Statute Has Grammatical Ambiguity? - November 16, 2026




