Parents Sue LA Teachers Union and LAUSD for Personal Injury to Kids for Continuing School Closures
Parents are living in fear of of union retaliation for advocating for their own children
By Timothy Snowball, March 31, 2021 10:03 am
It’s been a year since California Gov. Gavin Newsom first declared a state of emergency in March 2020 and authorized school closures across the state. In that year, we’ve learned a lot about the risks of COVID-19, and we’ve watched as other states have reopened schools and resumed in-person education.
Subsequent research now shows that allowing face-to-face instruction does not present a risk to either the children or the community, and school closures should be a last resort to prevent the spread of COVID-19.
Relatedly, we also know that forcing youngsters into online instruction can harm their mental, physical and academic well-being.
But none of this matters to United Teachers of Los Angeles (UTLA) and its president, Cecily Myart-Cruz. Instead of allowing its members to return to class months ago, UTLA has been holding the children of Los Angeles hostage as the price of advancing a political agenda.
And parents are ready to fight back.
On Tuesday, four families represented pro bono by the Freedom Foundation, a national non-profit advocacy organization that fights against the abuse of power by public employee unions, filed a first-of-its-kind personal injury lawsuit in California Superior Court against LAUSD, UTLA and UTLA’s fact-challenged president.
All we need to do is consult the record to see UTLA’s priorities.
As part of its initial call for school closures, UTLA released “10 Common Good Community Demands,” which included 15 additional paid sick days for all Los Angeles County workers, a weekly disaster stipend and creation of a food supply network.
None of these items had anything to do with student or teacher safety.
Last July, UTLA issued a revised list of demands for allowing its members to return to class. It included:
- defunding the police;
- enacting single-payer, government-provided healthcare;
- arranging for full funding for housing California’s homeless;
- closing all publicly funded charter schools in California;
- developing a new set of programs that address “systemic racism”; and,
- a $250-million payment from the federal government.
Again, none of these demands would do anything for student or teacher safety, and the subsequent words of Cecily Myart-Cruz leave no doubt that UTLA is more concerned with a political agenda than following the science or helping the kids.
On March 1, Myart-Cruz stated that Gov. Newsom’s re-opening plans were “propagating structural racism,” and claimed that minority communities are being “unfairly targeted by people who are not experiencing this disease in the same ways as students and families are in our communities.”
On March 2, Myart-Cruz again criticized Gov. Newsom’s school re-opening plan because, as she stated, it was being driven by “white wealthy parents,” and “(I)f this was a rich person’s disease, we would’ve seen a very different response.”
Myart-Cruz further stated that “(I)f you condition funding on the re-opening of schools, that money will only go to white and wealthier schools that do not have the transmission rates that low income black and brown communities do.”
Since the beginning of the pandemic, UTLA has been more interested in scoring political points it couldn’t achieve without holding Los Angeles children and parents hostage. While state and local officials try desperately to come up with a way to satisfy UTLA and other teacher union demands, it is the children of Los Angeles that continue to suffer.
The continued school closures have wreaked havoc on the lives of the parents in the lawsuit and their children, and children across Los Angeles. Plaintiff H.K.’s son has gone from an outgoing member of his class’s student government to socially isolated, suicidal and addicted to his computer.
Plaintiff A.S.’s son suffers from autism, and since the schools closed, has been unable to complete his classwork.
Plaintiffs A.P. and C.P.’s children began to experience emotional outbursts because of the stress of Zoom classes, and these parents had no choice but to place their children in private schools. This additional cost is borne by the families, adding additional pressure.
If you’re wondering why the parents are represented here (and in their court papers) by their initials instead of by their full names, it’s because they’re afraid of retaliation by UTLA and UTLA-affiliated teachers.
This is how bad the situation has become — parents living in fear of advocating for their own children because of the possibility of union retaliation. But left with no alternative to end their children’s suffering, they came to the Freedom Foundation for help in court.
In their lawsuit, the Los Angeles parents allegations are focused on the legal relationship between their children, LAUSD, and UTLA.
Under the well-established doctrine of in loco parentis, which is Latin for “in the place of a parent,” LAUSD has a legal responsibility to make decisions and act in the best interests of their students. By failing to return the students to class because of UTLA’s obstruction, LAUSD violated this responsibility.
What’s more, UTLA knew about LAUSD’s responsibility and the harm the plaintiffs’ children were suffering and still continued to prevent a return to class.
The parents are asking the court to recognize these legal relationships and their corresponding responsibilities, and to order that UTLA stop putting its political agenda over the health and well-being of the plaintiffs’ children and the other 600,000 students in LAUSD.
50 thoughts on “Parents Sue LA Teachers Union and LAUSD for Personal Injury to Kids for Continuing School Closures”
Who says there’s no good news! HA
Do agree with you!!! Terrific fight!!! Our kids are held hostage by these egomaniac who could care less about the suffering of all children.
How Do we Sign up to this Lawsuit? I am a parent that has been emailing the school since last year and no one from LAUSD ever got back to me.
FYI: Below is the website for Freedom Foundation, where the author of the article is an attorney:
Please let me know if you find someone please here my email email@example.com thank you ill appreciate it..
Cecily Myart-Cruz Is a racist and the rest of the leadership at UTLA are complicit in her divisive agenda. The children of Los Angeles have suffered and will deal with issues in their development due to her selfish and unreasonable choices.
How can this become a class action lawsuit?
How can more sign up for this heroic effort!
How can the community jump on board to this sign of hope?!?!
They look like a real happy group of people………
Really. Imagine the UN-POSED photo. HA
First thought that came to mind. Except I had a more sinister feeling. Ew. Very strange looking people. Do they look like they have the children’s best interests in mind?
You said it, K. I sure as heck wouldn’t leave any kids in my care with this group. 🙂
(Of course they are not rank-and-file teachers, just union hacks.)
These entire UTLA Reps. Need to be Locked up!
So many children and families have suffered due to UTLA negligence!
We ALL Know they are being funded by Lobbyist for their Agenda of Destroying our Children and their Education!
Lock up UTLA Reps!
So many children and families have suffered due to UTLA negligence!
We Know they are being funded by Lobbyist for their Agenda of Destroying our Children and their Education!
Get involved, join California School Choice Foundation. Go to http://www.californiaschoolchoice.org/
In the meantime, get your kids out of public school. Just when you think it can’t get any worse than it is today, they implement a critical race theory and BLM curriculum. Remember, everyday that your kid is enrolled, the public school gets allocated funding. Get out now. What do you have to lose? Really?
The threats of violence are very real! It was very brave of them to file the lawsuit. UTLA has committed assaults and vandalism as intimidation tactics. LAUSD throws away files and records that might make them look bad. Just Google Mark Berndt or his UTLA rep Ingrid Villeda, you’ll see how far UTLA and LAUSD are willing to go to hide and destroy records!