Home>Congress>Katie Hill Cuts Goofy Ad for Christy Smith
Assemblywoman Christy Smith (Photo: Kevin Sanders for California Globe)
State Rep. Christy Smith. (Photo: Kevin Sanders for California Globe)

Katie Hill Cuts Goofy Ad for Christy Smith

Disgraced rep weighs in on CA-25 amid shocking Garcia surge

By Ken Kurson, May 10, 2020 10:00 am

Christy Smith
State Rep. Christy Smith is in an unexpectedly tight race for Congress against Mike Garcia. (Photo: Kevin Sanders for California Globe)

For weeks now, the race in California 25 has been tightening. When freshman incumbent Katie Hill was forced to resign amid accusations of sexual and other workplace improprieties, it was assumed that her 8-point victory over incumbent Republican Steve Knight in November 2018 was part of an inexorable march that had turned almost all of California’s suburbs blue.

All of a sudden, however, a strong Republican candidate, a costly gaffe by the Democrat, and frustration among socially liberal but fiscally conservative suburbanites have combined to make this interesting.

The national press has taken notice.

Politico ran an article on Friday all but conceding defeat for the Democrats, who are said to be turning their attention to the November re-do, when the presidential race will presumably restore turn-out and put the seat back in Democratic hands.

But Republicans, desperate for any sign of good news in a state that has virtually outlawed their existence, see in Mike Garcia the makings of a trend.

The comeback began with an unforced error by the Democratic candidate, Assemblywoman Christy Smith (AD-38). Smith had herself turned her seat from red to blue in 2018 with a 51-49 squeaker over incumbent Republican Dante Acosta.

Garcia, a first-generation American who graduated in the top 3% at Annapolis, became a naval pilot who was first in his class in flight school. He participated in over 30 combat sorties in Iraq before moving back home to work for Raytheon.

With aerospace and defense playing an outsized role in the 25th District, both voters and the DCCC were aghast when a recording leaked in which Smith mocked Garcia for his military service. On a Zoom call with campaign staff and supporters, Smith made light of Garcia’s supposed over-reliance on his background during the campaign.

“Did you guys know he’s a pilot? I … you know … it had escaped me.” Amid much laughter, Smith adds, “OK, he’s got pictures of planes behind him and I’ve got constitutional law books.” An unidentified man opines, “I love that being a pilot gives him experience and knowledge in international affairs.” Smith joins in the chuckling.

Smith, who is well-regarded as a moderate legislator, has since issued a sorry-not-sorry apology for comments that “might suggest” disrespect. But the damage seems to have been done. The DCCC spent over $1 million last Fall trying to manipulate the primary. National Democrats wanted Smith to face off against Knight, who announced his comeback bid when Hill resigned. But Garcia surged and with that million completely wasted, the national organization seems content to sit it out until November.

Katie Hill Dives In

And now, amid the dynamic of a surging Garcia and a struggling Smith, Katie Hill herself has maladroitly barged into the race.

Last week Hill cut an unusually self-serving and idiotic ad that seems to have actually hurt the Democratic candidate she’s endorsed to replace her.

A straight-to-camera, dizzy-making shot of her walking around in Washington shows a masked Hill looking more Patty Hearst than PPE. She dramatically removes her black mask to reveal, “It’s me, Katie Hill.” As if anyone knows who she is simply by appearance. She alludes to “that building right behind me,” apparently meaning the White House, but it’s so sunny it’s impossible to see what she’s talking about. And the music seems chosen by someone making his first iMovie trailer.

The whole thing is remarkably tone deaf for someone who was forced to resign from Congress after just a year. Predictably, the ad already has four times as many dislikes as likes, and the comments are brutal.

In a quote that was shockingly tone deaf even for the coiner of the unforgettable “throuple,” Hill said that the reason she’s spending $200,000 of her PAC’s money on a race whose winner is looking at a five-month term, is all about her. “I do not want my legacy to be flipping a seat, and then having it immediately flipped back,” she told Politico.

It’s a lot of drama and expense for a race that will only have to be re-run a few months from now. Clearly, both parties see California 25 as a harbinger of what’s to come. Will the suburbs, worried about Coronavirus and the president’s rhetoric, continue abandoning the Republicans? Or will middle-class voters fed up with the shutdown return to the party that’s advocating for quickly getting back to work? On Tuesday, the whole country will get an early indicator.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Spread the news:


14 thoughts on “Katie Hill Cuts Goofy Ad for Christy Smith

  1. The nasty-mocking attitudes and humorless arrogance are enough by themselves to reject the ridiculous Christy Smith and the “not helping” Katie Hill Dem faction. So annoying and clueless it’s comical.

    Glad to hear Mike Garcia is surging as he should be. Great candidate. Get out the vote for Mike Garcia and overwhelm the harvesters and other cheaters.

  2. Exactly who forced Katie to resign? It is mentioned a couple of times, NOBODY forced her, she quit then claimed VICTIM! Her supposed shoe in replacement who seems to think that she Knows the Constitution better than a Naval Pilot is such an example of arrogance and hubris and ignorance and is a fine example of the Trash we send to Sacramento, some of which winds up in DC too I’m afraid.

  3. It is entirely Katie Hill’s fault that the Dems have lost a valuable seat in Congress. Period.

  4. It is entirely Katie Hill’s fault that we have lost this Democratic seat in a GOP stronghold. We will lose it again in the fall without a stronger candidate who at least shows some respect to strong competition. Christy Smith is not that person.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *