Prison Cell Bars (Photo: Dan Henson/Shutterstock)
Can Governor Newsom Legally Commute Death Penalty Sentences?
The Governor’s discretion is based ‘on conditions the Governor deems proper’
By Chris Micheli, November 21, 2026 11:23 am
On November 5, 2026, Governor Gavin Newsom announced plans to commute all 548 California death row prisoners’ sentences to life in state prison without the possibility of parole. Since then, a debate has ensued whether the Governor has a legal right to do so. And, just recently, a lawsuit was filed to challenge his blanket commutation.
According to the ACLU, “Newsom is not alone in commuting death sentences. Since 1976, seven governors and former President Joe Biden have commuted all or most death sentences in their jurisdictions, based on systemic circumstances not specific to any individual. These commutations were granted in states like Maryland and Illinois by governors of both political parties.”
So, can Governor Newsom legal commute death penalty sentences? We start our analysis with the California Constitution. Article V, Section 8(a) states in full:
(a) Subject to application procedures provided by statute, the Governor, on conditions the Governor deems proper, may grant a reprieve, pardon, and commutation, after sentence, except in case of impeachment. The Governor shall report to the Legislature each reprieve, pardon, and commutation granted, stating the pertinent facts and the reasons for granting it. The Governor may not grant a pardon or commutation to a person twice convicted of a felony except on recommendation of the Supreme Court, 4 judges concurring.
(Sec. 8 amended Nov. 8, 1988, by Prop. 89. Res.Ch. 63, 1988.)
Under the California Constitution, Governor Newsom has the authority to commute death sentences to life in prison without parole, though cases involving multiple felony convictions require approval from a majority of the justices of the California Supreme Court.
How does commuting sentences work in California? Governor Newsom can unilaterally commute sentences for condemned prisoners convicted of a felony in connection with a single incident, which is about one-third of the current death row cases. The word “may,” which is discretionary, is used Section 8(a). As a result, the Governor has the authority to grant a commutation after sentence, with one exception (impeachment).
In addition, the Governor’s discretion is based “on conditions the Governor deems proper.” As a result, these conditions can be objective or subjective based upon the Governor’s discretion. Once the Governor’s decision has been made, then he or she must report each commutation to the Legislature, “stating the pertinent facts and the reasons for granting it.” This final requirement could be interpreted as requiring the Governor to review each commutation. However, he could use the same reason(s) for all of the commutations.
For prisoners with more than one felony conviction (about 70% of the cases), at least four of the seven justices on the California Supreme Court must approve the commutation before it can be actually granted. Governor Newsom has not had any of his commutation applications denied by the state’s high court during his eight years in office. We will see if that statistic remains intact after the Court’s review of 382 applications. However, considering his current rate of success, we can assume that at least four justices will likely approve all of his requests.
Remember that a commutation changes the punishment from death to life without parole in state prison. The commutation does not release prisoners nor overturn their convictions, nor do the commutations repeal California’s death penalty statute nor stop prosecutors from seeking new death sentences in future cases.
Following the Governor’s announcement earlier this month, prosecutors, law enforcement groups, and victims’ families filed a petition with the California Supreme Court seeking to block the commutations, arguing Governor Newsom abused his power and bypassed legal requirements.
This lawsuit is unlikely to succeed because the Governor’s clemency power (like the President’s) is constitutionally established and Governor Newsom is following the required process by submitting multiple-felony cases to the state’s high court.
The reason for this prediction is that California’s courts have historically treated the Governor’s commutation power as broad and only constrained by separation of powers principles, while twice-convicted inmates still require state Supreme Court agreement.
For example, in Procedures for Considering Requests for Recommendations Concerning Applications for Pardon or Commutation (2018) 4 Cal. 5th 897, the California Supreme Court explained its constitutional role when reviewing clemency requests involving twice-convicted felons. The state’s high court explained that the clemency power rests with the Governor and that the court does not decide the substantive merits of whether mercy should be granted.
Rather, the court’s only role is to evaluate whether there is sufficient support that granting clemency would not be an abuse of power, rooted in separation of powers and historical safeguards against untoward influence. As a result, the only basis for the lawsuit to be successful is whether the high court would view the actions of Governor Newsom as an “abuse of power.” Again, from my perspective, that outcome is doubtful because of the broad grant of authority given to him by the state Constitution, and that a his commutations are based “on conditions the Governor deems proper,” which is also consistent with Article V, Section 8(a).
- Can Governor Newsom Legally Commute Death Penalty Sentences? - November 21, 2026
- Comparing the California and Federal Administrative Procedure Acts - November 21, 2026
- Exploring Grammatical and Punctuation Canons - November 20, 2026




